Feedback

What's your question?

By: Asked

How many exposures are needed for a good quality HDR image?

You can construct an high dynamic range image out of multiple exposures, but how many are needed for a good one? At what point does adding exposures not result in improved quality?

Add comment viewed 724 times Latest activity 11 months ago

or Cancel

5 answers

  • 2

chas jarrett

It's also partly about the time constraints. It can be difficult to clear a set for enough time to shoot the best HDRI possible.

If you're shooting a 360 degree hdr environment map with a 180 degree (8mm fisheye) lens then I usually shoot 3 directions at 120 degrees apart to avoid vignetting at the edges/seam. With 9 exposures per direction - that's 27 images to shoot per hdri - which is sometimes not possible.

I usually shoot 5 exposures, 3 stops apart -6, -3, on-aim, +3, +6. This covers the same exposure range as 7 images at 2 stops apart but with fewer images. Doesn't suit all conditions but works as a general purpose setup for me.

or Cancel
  • 2

sambo

It varies depending on the intended use. All the best plans and science fall apart when the first AD wants to move on, people in bright orange safety vests are milling around and the clouds are doing 200km/h. I think I can grab a sphere in about 3 minutes, at least that's the time I quote to the first and give them a lot of warning.

The method passed on to me by our lighters that I use (no complaints, yet) shooting with an 8mm/5dmkII on a nodal ninja goes like :

  • Have the damn thing ready, cap off, remember to remove the extra cuff found on fishies.
  • Get assistant/data to help level the ninja, check the measurements on the side so we have zero parallax and the sphere is somewhat aligned.
  • assistant/data do notes for card/image number, time and any relevant easy survey.
  • Point the camera at the sun or the fattest light, go to like f6-8 iso100 usually, best compromise for flare etc and the flare will hopefully be small and in one shot.
  • Head straight to quickest shutter and bang one off, see if it's clipping if not, start clicking.
  • Shoot with a 3 'click' gap unless the lighters have asked for different. I don't read the camera display, just count clicks and shoot as fast as possible.
  • Keep shooting, when your shutter time is long enough to almost clip out the frame, it's time to rotate the ninja 120 degrees and start at the bottom.

I find the hardest part about that is convincing people to move out of the shot when you're on 8mm. "nope you're still in, yep still in, safest behind me, click"

or Cancel
  • 1

andrew marshall [ Editor ]

Depends, largely, on two things.

  1. The dynamic range of the scene you're shooting. Essentially, the shortest exposure should be short enough so that the brightest areas of the scene are not overexposed, and the longest should be long enough so that the darkest regions are not under exposed.

  2. The response curve of the camera. This is a non linear function that maps the actual scene radiance to the pixel value recorded by the CCD. This function can be estimated in advance ( as it is dependent on the cmaera, and not the scene ), also from multiple exposures. In which case, a sequence 3 stops apart between the darkest and lightest image will be sufficient. If you don't have the response curve, try a sequence 1 stop apart.

For a full explanation, see Debevec and Malik; (Recovering high dynamic range radiance maps from photographs) or Mitsunaga and Nayar; (Radiometric self calibration) via ACM or IEEE respectively.

NN comments
wrosecrans
-

++ to the fact that the dynamic range of the scene has to be taken into account for a “correct” answer. Basically, the most important rule of thump there will be based on if the sun is directly visible, or if the sun isn’t in the image then are there any big lights. For an outdoor scene at dusk when you can’t see the sun, you can capture an accurate HDR with limited range. The same scene at noon will require a much higher range if you want accurate lighting from the HDR showing the true brightness of the sun.

or Cancel
  • 1

hugh_gid [ Editor ]

If you're using a camera with auto exposure bracketing, then 9 is a good number to use - set the AEB to go +/- 2 stops, then dial 6 stops between each group of 3 photos...

or Cancel